I don't often use Pastepunk as a soapbox to be critical of the independent music label community, but every now and then, something comes across my way that sticks around in my head and strikes a nerve. Today's mail brought on such a feeling.
<br><br>
Exhibit A is a release from Thick Records by a now defunct Chicago band named TRENCHMOUTH that existed primarily in the early to mid 90s. I had never heard them, and quite frankly, I doubt most people not from Chicago are too familar with them. The bio however, truly made me want to check them out, as it contained a brief history of the band and continued examples of the exhuberance the band felt to play live and tour the country when they had the chance. Included in the latter half of the bio was the line, "We got to tour Europe towards the end of our run. That was a dream ceom true for us. Doesn't matter what we sounded like, it was the enthusiasm and the energy of the people who came to see us that meant the most to us."
<br><br>
Exhibit B is unfortunate. The label responsible for this bio, Uprising Records should be ashamed of themselves. The band, FALL OUT BOY, who have now signed to Fueled By Ramen Records are infact very talented, and my anger here is in no way pointed towards them. But back to the bio…I will quote this almost in its entirety:
<br><br><i>"A pristine pop punk platter to make the pretty girls swoon if ever there was one, Fall Out Boy's debut delivers. Complete with the invigorating punch of New Found Glory, the melodic sensitivities of Saves The Day, and the smart arrangements of Blink 182 combined. From here on out, when you think stylish, perfectly crafted emo-pop-punk, think Fall Out Boy."</i>
<br><br>
I don't blame Uprising for name-dropping some of the heavyweight bands around at the moment in this bio, but if this is not one of the most blatant examples between a label putting out music that they genuinely feel <b>needs</b> to be heard, versus a label chasing a rising cash flow, banking on a predictable, played out sound, I don't know what is.
<br><br>
I don't have a tidy way to tie up the point that's been made, but I can hypothetically ask myself and all of you, "how much of this is really about the music, anyway?" I hope your content with your answer – at least I know Thick Records is.